Reviews
Part of Online Business Banks: Audit the Branch Jobs You Would Lose
8 parts of online business banks cost, explained
Eight cost parts make up an online business bank bill, and only the first four, the visible fee schedule, ever appear on the statement you are shown.
A branchless account publishes a short fee schedule, and that shortness is the pitch. For most businesses the schedule is the smaller half of the bill. The rest arrives as third-party charges, workarounds and your own hours.
None of it is hidden on purpose. It simply lands somewhere other than the pricing page. What follows names all eight parts, says which four you can see before you apply, and shows how to price the four you cannot.
What to take away
- Eight cost parts make up the billfour on the fee schedule, four off it.
- Cash deposits and cross-border margin are the two off-schedule parts that swing the total most.
- A missing feature costs money three waysdone by hand, done by another provider, or not done at all.
- Redundancy is a real line item, and usually the cheapest insurance in the comparison.
- Price your own cash, margin and hours before you read anyone's schedule.
The four parts you can see
These four sit in the published schedule. Ask for all of them in writing before you apply.
- Account maintenance.A monthly charge, sometimes waived above a balance you must hold. The balance is the real price.
- Transaction charges.Per-item fees on deposits, withdrawals, transfers and card payments. Volume decides whether these matter.
- Payment and transfer charges.What the bank takes on outgoing wires, e-transfers and batch payments, separate from what the rail charges.
- Exception charges.Overdrafts, returned items, stop payments, paper statements, replacement cards. Low headline pricing is often recovered here.
Read the exception column first. That is where a cheap-looking account earns its money back.
The four parts you cannot see
These four never appear on a schedule, and they are where branchless accounts differ from each other most.
- Third-party charges.Cash deposit points, couriers and currency desks bill you directly, on their own terms, not your provider's.
- Exchange-rate margin.The gap between the rate you are quoted and the reference market rate on the same day. It is the main cost of any cross-border payment.
- Your own hours.Trips to a deposit point, manual reconciliation, rekeying data, waiting on support. Value the time at what that person costs you per hour, employment costs included.
- Exposure and downtime.Payments blocked during an outage, funds frozen during a review, and the cost of a missed payroll or supplier date.
The first four are the only ones most comparisons cover. The last four get worse as a business grows.
Where online business bank cost lands
Charged by provider
- What it looks like
- Maintenance, item, payment charges
- Where the number is
- Fee schedule, in writing
- Covered by comparisons
- Yes, usually
- As business grows
- Scales with volume
Charged by someone else
- What it looks like
- Cash points, agents, couriers
- Where the number is
- Their own published terms
- Covered by comparisons
- Rarely
- As business grows
- Scales with cash volume
Paid in hours
- What it looks like
- Trips, reconciliation, rekeying
- Where the number is
- Your own time, costed
- Covered by comparisons
- Almost never
- As business grows
- Scales with headcount
Paid in exposure
- What it looks like
- Blocked payments, funds on hold
- Where the number is
- Payment calendar, missed dates
- Covered by comparisons
- Almost never
- As business grows
- Scales with payment value
Cash is the widest gap
If any part of the business is paid in notes and coin, price this first. It is often the deciding number.
Costing a cash banking trip
- Find where a deposit can physically be made
- Measure distance from where cash is taken
- Check who chargesprovider, location, or both
- Establish how coin is handled and priced
- Add travel, queue and staff time
- Add the deposit charge itself
- Multiply by trips per month
Ask three questions before any comparison. Where can a deposit physically be made, and how far is that from where the money is taken? Who charges for it, the provider or the location or both? And what happens to coin, which is treated differently almost everywhere?
Then work out the cost per trip: travel, queue time, the person not working while they stand in it, plus whatever the deposit itself costs. Multiply by how often you would go.
A business taking cash daily often sees this line exceed every listed fee combined. Cash handling belongs in the decision, not the footnotes.
Cross-border payments are priced twice
Where money crosses currencies, the visible charge is rarely the main cost. The margin applied to the exchange rate never appears on a fee schedule, and institutions in the middle can deduct amounts in transit.
Compare your quoted rate against the reference market rate from the same day, using your own past transactions, and record the difference as a cost.
Before sending, ask who bears the charges along the route and what the recipient will actually receive. The way different routes handle this is set out in how payment rails differ.
Pricing a missing feature
Every capability the account lacks is either done another way or not done at all. Both have a cost.
- Done by hand.Count the minutes, multiply by frequency, and value the time at what the person doing it actually costs you per hour, including employment costs.
- Done by another provider.Add their charges and the cost of keeping a second relationship alive, including any balance you have to strand to satisfy their conditions.
- Not done.Payments you cannot make, customers you cannot bill the way they want, or reconciliation you skip. Harder to value and usually the most expensive of the three.
Software integration belongs here too. If transactions do not export in a form your bookkeeping accepts, someone rekeys them every month, forever. That cost shows up in nobody's comparison and in everybody's evenings.
Support and downtime are costs, not qualities
A provider with no route to a person is cheaper to run and moves the cost to you. Work out what a blocked payment day would cost: the supplier who stops shipping, the payroll that runs late, the hours spent on a chat window.
You do not need a probability estimate. A business with no fallback carries that risk in full.
This is the argument for a second banking relationship, and it deserves its own line in the total. A redundant account carries charges, may require a balance to be held, and takes time to maintain. It also converts a total outage into an inconvenience, which is usually the best value in the whole comparison.
What genuinely tends to cost less
Branchless providers are not simply cheaper accounts with things removed, and it is worth being even-handed.
Account opening and administration tend to consume fewer of your hours. Multi-user access, permissions and card controls are often better and cost nothing extra. Data usually comes out in machine-readable form, which saves real bookkeeping time. And the absence of a branch network genuinely removes costs that other institutions have to recover somewhere.
The point is not that one model is cheaper. It is that the cost sits in different places, so a comparison that only reads fee schedules compares the wrong halves. The taxonomy for reading any schedule properly is in how charges group together.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the complete fee schedule, including exception charges, in writing?
- Where and how can cash be deposited, and who charges for it?
- What is charged on incoming payments, including from platforms and card processors?
- How is the exchange rate set on cross-border payments, and who bears the route charges?
- What is the process and the wait when a payment is delayed or a balance is under review?
- What data can I export, in what format, and does it include everything I need for reconciliation?
- What does it cost to close the account and move, and how long does a full withdrawal take?
Get the answers before the application rather than after, since the whole picture of what to have ready is in what a remote application demands.
Where to start
Price your cash handling, your cross-border margin and your workaround hours before you read a single fee schedule. If those three are small for your business, the schedule is the whole story. If they are not, the schedule is a distraction.
Common questions
Are branchless accounts cheaper overall?
For a business with little cash, mostly electronic payments and a tolerance for support by message, often yes. For a cash-intensive business, or one that needs a person on the phone, frequently not once the workarounds are priced. The honest answer depends on inputs only you have.
How should I compare a low-fee provider against a traditional institution?
Apply both schedules to your own twelve months of activity, then add the four off-schedule parts: third-party charges, exchange margin, your hours and the cost of redundancy. Compare the totals, not the headline pricing.
Is a free account actually free?
It is free of a maintenance charge. Whether it is free depends on what you do that it cannot, and on what you would have to build around it. Read the exception charges especially closely, since that is where a low headline is often recovered.
Does the provider being cheap say anything about its stability?
Not directly, but it is a reason to ask who holds the money and whether the balance is a deposit. Coverage exists at insured banks and insured credit unions, with limits and conditions set by the insurer.
Published as deposit insurance rules by the FDIC and share insurance material by the NCUA, and wider trade-offs are covered in what a branch was quietly doing.
